Investigators have concluded the Apple Fire in southern California near Cherry Valley was caused by hot carbon particles from the exhaust system of a diesel-powered truck, which is not an uncommon cause of vegetation fires along roadways. Witnesses corroborated the investigators findings. At least three ignition points were found which all merged into one fire.
All internal combustion engines emit carbon particles which is why spark arrestors are required on chain saws, for example. The smallest are invisible, but particles from diesel engines can be much larger than those from small engines or gasoline engines. The bigger the engine, the larger the particles. As a qualified Cause and Origin Investigator I have picked up along railroads particles that were two inches long.
(To see all articles on Wildfire Today about the Apple Fire, including the most recent, click here.)
When a diesel engine begins ejecting carbon particles it can occur over a distance along a road or railroad. Multiple fire ignition points can be created.
Volatile hydrocarbons contained within the particle may extend the time the particle is thermally active. Larger particles may auto-ignite upon ejection and contact with the air.
A Diesel engine is more likely to throw out large carbon particles if it has been idling, it has suddenly been throttled up (such as pulling a heavy load up a hill), or if the engine is not running properly.
A discarded lit cigarette usually will not ignite dry grass unless the relative humidity is less than 22 to 25 percent, but carbon particles have been known to start fires at up to 80 percent. Many fires along roads blindly blamed on “someone tossing a cigarette” are more likely caused by hot carbon particles.
Pieces of catalytic converters can also be discharged from exhaust pipes. Normally catalytic converters can reach up to 1,380°F. When they malfunction and overheat they can break apart at temperatures of 2,400 to 2,800°F. Hot ceramic particles discharge from the exhaust system either through the tail pipe or through failures in the outer shell of the converter itself.
To learn more about investigating the cause of vegetation fires, spend some time with the 337-page “Guide to Wildland Fire Origin and Cause Determination” (NWCG publication, PMS 412).
All data must be considered and evaluated. Possible ignition sources that are not supported by facts are removed from the equation during the scientific process. There are many examples that every wildland fire investigator can recite about “eyewitness” accounts. Eyewitness accounts hold weight when they are supported by facts or other data unbeknownst to the eyewitness. There are many times that good samaritans are dubbed the arsonist because they were seen at the fire during the early onset.
There have been too many different versions as to the cause of the Apple Fire in Cherry Valley.
First a witness called 911 to report a man setting fires walking down Apple Tree Lane.
Then a diesel truck caused it.
Today, a 20 year old man was arrested and charged with setting the fire.
Never made public were the teenagers by the old school house in Oak Glen that had a bag filled with lighter fluid and cigarette lighters and were arrested by law enforcement.
Why so many versions and is their a cover-up going on?
I wonder what happenjed to the initial story about the teenagers setting 2 fires, including one at the old schoolhouse in the Oka Glen area??? A longtime local resident of Oak Glen said they were from influential families. Suddenly the story has changed as to the cause of the fire and it is a vehicle.
Speculation VS scientific investigation. Investigators will consider every bit of information they receive, but that won’t necessarily be made public. Reasonable certainty dictates that.