A new audit by the Department of Homeland Security’s Office of Inspector General that examined payments made by the Federal Emergency Management Agency to the state of California for helping to suppress wildfires in southern California in 2007, questions some of the charges. It concluded that of the $122 million total that was paid to the state, “the Department did not properly request additional funding for a cost overrun exceeding $80 million”. A portion of the overruns, $6.6 million, was in “ineligible labor costs”. The audit said that FEMA agreed with “parts” of the OIG’s findings regarding the labor charges, but did not say specifically which parts they agreed or disagreed with.
While CalFire pays their firefighters portal-to-portal 24 hours a day while they are on fire assignments, the FEMA policy stipulates that after the first 48 hours they will only reimburse for 16 hours a day “even when the applicant is contractually obligated to pay for 24 hour shifts”.
The audit recommends that $12.6 million of the charges be disallowed, and to “require the Department to review its costs incurred and submit a revised claim based on supporting documentation and applicable federal criteria”.
Some federal wildland firefighters are trying to get legislation passed to enable portal-to-portal fire pay for the federal land management agencies. If they are successful, that would put FEMA in an awkward position.
Note, March 20, 2011: we modified this article to clarify that the audit was conducted by the DHS’s Office of Inspector General. FEMA is an agency within the DHS. The audit report can be found here.












