More extreme wildfires are headed for New Mexico, tree stress shows

Moisture within Ponderosa pine trees is a significant indicator of future extreme wildfire forecasts, according to new study published in the Fire Ecology journal.

Researchers with the Los Alamos National Laboratory and the University of Texas at Austin recently studied New Mexico’s Bandelier National Monument and found that moisture stress within the trees is projected to extend fire seasons annually in the area.

The national monument was the site of the 2011 Las Conchas Fire, which became the state’s largest wildfire before being surpassed by the Whitewater-Baldy Fire in 2012, the Black Fire in 2022, and the Calf Canyon-Hermits Peak Fire in 2022. The Las Conchas Fire burned over 156,000 acres after it was ignited by a tree falling onto a power line above extremely flammable vegetation, according to the National Park Service.

Live fuel moisture content, or the amount of water in living plant tissues, is crucial to the prediction of climate impacts on fire regimes, according to the researchers. Higher moisture content typically corresponds to lower flammability, due to the energy required to evaporate the moisture before the plants can combust.

“Traditional fire risk indices are calculated through empirical relationships derived exclusively from weather and seasonal timing,” the researchers said. “While these have been used to estimate the change in future fire risk, they do so without considering the crucial thresholds that plants may cross. Key to predicting fire behavior is an understanding of how the plant carbon and water cycles alter fuel availability (live or dead vegetation available to burn) under non-analog climate conditions.”

The researchers used Ponderosa pine trees as their focus because they’re widespread throughout the Rocky Mountains, ranging from Montana to northern Mexico and east to Texas. They then built a model to simulate how future moisture stress in the trees would be affected by projected climate changes.

They determined that the number of days that the trees experience stress is projected to significantly increase under multiple climate scenarios. The increase is expected to extend the state’s usual fire season into later in the year.

“The overall increase in plant water stress (as represented by loss of hydraulic conductivity and leaf water potential) and lower live fuel moisture appear to be driven by reduced precipitation during late summer monsoons typical of the region,” the researchers said. “We predict increasing variability in the P. ponderosa wildfire regime under both climate projections driven by changing productivity, rising mortality, and an overall decrease in live fuel moisture.”

Climbing trees to harvest pine cones after the Wallow Fire in Arizona

Wallow Fire
Engine crew works on the Wallow Fire in 2011. Photo by Jayson Coil.

On a recent October day south and west of Alpine, AZ, James Nesslage and Brandon Billy were harvesting a bumper crop of cones from the top branches of a 100-foot tall ponderosa pine. That tree and others like it are survivors of the 538,049-acre Wallow Fire that burned in eastern Arizona and western New Mexico in 2011, most of it within the Apache-Sitgreaves National Forest. The cones being picked will yield the seeds needed to continue the restoration of parts of that vast burn.

picking pine cones
James Nesslage climbs a rope rigged in a 100-foot ponderosa pine tree as as he and his crew prepare to harvest seed cones on the Apache-Sitgreaves National Forest southwest of Alpine, AZ. Photo by Tom Story.

Plans to restore the forest began before the Wallow Fire was contained. Initial estimates were that high burn severity over much of the fire area would result in natural regeneration being hampered by a lack of available seed trees.

To have the best chance of survival, seedlings must be grown from cones taken from parent trees in the area. Patrick Murphy, silviculturist on the Apache-Sitgreaves, explained:

Several factors are used in determining where cones are harvested and from which trees seed is collected.  The forest has pre-established “seed zones”.  These seed zones are geographic locations found throughout the forest.  In collecting seed we take into consideration if the parent tree is free from insects, disease, defects, deformity, or forking.  The tree should also exhibit superior height and diameter growth.  We will plant seedlings in the same seed zone and elevation band where the parent tree is located.

Earlier in the year, there was a larger crew of 20 people harvesting the seed cones. Now as the cone picking season, which began in mid-August, was winding down, there were only two other people; father and son Randy and Brandon James, working that day.  It would take two to three hours for each team to completely strip the tree of its cones. “The contract specifies eighty-percent (of the cones on each tree)” said Mr. Nesslage, “but we try to do better than that”. The pine that the James duo picked that morning barely produced a bushel of good cones while the tree that Mr. Nesslage and Mr. Billy harvested yielded over three bushels.

picking pine cones
Brandon Billy works his way out on a limb as James Nesslage (mostly hidden at right) uses a hook to pull the cone laden tip of a limb close to Mr. Billy during the seed cone harvest. Photo by Tom Story.

A general contractor in the construction business, Mr. Nesslage came across a solicitation for a seed cone harvesting contract on the Federal Business Opportunities website and thought it was a chance to put some of his climbing experience to good use. “Go camping, climb trees and get paid for it! Sweet!” was his reaction. He was awarded a contract and started picking in 2012.  He admitted that the learning curve was a little steep at first but was able to complete the harvest. The cone crop in 2013 was poor and was not picked, so when Mr. Nesslage’s teams returned to the woods this year, not only was there more to harvest, they had a larger crew and more knowledge of how to do the job better and more efficiently.

Continue reading