Lessons learned from 3 wildfire incidents

The Wildland Fire Lessons Learned Center has posted reports from three recent incidents: an escaped prescribed fire that burned private land, an injury caused by an air tanker drop, and wheels that loosened and fell off an engine, hitting a passenger car. We commend the folks involved in these incidents, sharing their experiences so that others may learn.

Here are summaries of the three reports:

Escaped fire from pile burning on Black Hills National Forest

Escaped prescribed fire Black Hills National Forest

On January 13, 2012 during pile burning operations on the Black Hills National Forest 10 miles west of Rapid City, South Dakota, 9-15 mph winds gusting at 23-37 mph contributed to the fire escaping from the piles and burning onto private land. After driving to a USFS facility to obtain fire tools, the three firefighters on scene fought the fire for two hours before notifying the zone fire management officer.

Here is the executive summary from the report:

On January 13, 2012, fire personnel from Northern Hills Ranger District of the Black Hills National Forest ignited approximately 150 hand piles within the Forest Health Unit 1 fuel break. As the three-person burn team completed ignition around noon, the relative humidity dropped rapidly while brisk westerly winds developed. The combined effect of the pre-heating from the burning piles and the drying wind quickly evaporated the two inches of snow covering the heavy fuels immediately upslope from the burning piles. As the fire began to spread by means of spotting from log-to-log, the burn team worked diligently to contain the spots. Buffeted by wind gusts in excess of 35 mph during the afternoon and evening, the fire burned approximately 3.5 acres of private property.

During the escape, the affected landowner became dissatisfied by a perceived lack of regard shown by the Forest Service and shared his frustrations via telephone with the Acting District Ranger who, in turn, advised the off-duty Zone FMO that the fire had burned onto private property. Additional resources arrived on scene. The Forest Health Prescribed Fire was declared a wildfire, and became known as the Picnic Fire. Command transferred from the RXB3 to an ICT4, and the Picnic Fire was declared contained the following day. No structures or improvements were damaged by the fire.

Wheels come off BLM engine and hit passenger car

BLM Engine 2423 and tow truck

The crew of a Bureau of Land Management engine removed, painted, and re-installed the wheels of their engine in preparation for a 4th of July parade. The following day they experienced a problem.

BLM Engine 2423 and automobile

Here is an excerpt from the Introduction section of the report:

On Wednesday June 29, 2011, E-423, a Type-4 wildland fire engine was travelling south on US-395 returning to the Burns Interagency Fire Station in Hines, Oregon after visiting a recently controlled fire incident. In route to the station, the rear driver’s side dual lug nuts loosened and fell off causing the wheels to separate from the vehicle. One of the free wheels from the engine traveled into the opposing lane of traffic and struck a passing motorist causing damage to the frontend of the passenger side of the vehicle. E-423 came to rest on the left rear hub and sustained damage to the brake/hub assembly and surface damage to the rear body box. No serious injuries were sustained as a result of the incident.

Firefighter injured by air tanker drop

This is the complete narrative section of the report:

On January 13, 2012, units from CAL FIRE Riverside Unit/Riverside County Fire Department were dispatched to a vegetation fire in the Cherry Valley area near Oak Glen Rd. and Apple Tree Ln. The fire occurred mid-slope on a very steep hillside. The engine company had been assigned to determine if there was a good location to access the fire and start a hose lay. A Helitack Fire Captain was acting as a lookout and notified all personnel operating in the area that airtankers were about to make air drops. Communication was established both face to face and over the radio. A Fire Apparatus Engineer assigned to an engine was approximately 50’-60’ downhill from the ridgeline near the flank of the fire. The FAE acknowledged the notification of incoming air drops. An air tanker then came over the ridge and began its drop run . The FAE saw the air tanker at the last second and discarded his tool but was unable to get into the proper safety position for the drop. He was struck by the drop causing him to roll approximately 50’-60’ feet down the steep slope.

The FAE was immediately attended to by onscene personnel. The FAE was able to walk to the ridge with assistance and then transported by Copter 301 to a helispot where a private ambulance was waiting. The ambulance transported the FAE to a local trauma center for evaluation. The FAE was evaluated and released within a few hours with minor injuries.

 

Photos of Tanker 40 at Prince Edward Island

Tanker 40 at PEI
Tanker 40 taking off at Summerside Airport on Prince Edward Island in Canada. Photo by Rob Sowald, and used with his permission.

These photos of air tanker 40 were taken by Rob Sowald as it was taking off from runway 24 at Summerside airport on Prince Edward Island on February 26. The aircraft had been at the Tronos facility in Canada since December undergoing a C-check, which for a BAe-146 is required every 5,000 cycles or every 2.5 years. It was beginning its trip back to Missoula, Montana where it is leased by Neptune Aviation for the upcoming wildfire season. The company has interim approval from the Interagency Air Tanker Board for the aircraft to be used on wildfires through December, 2012, after which it will be considered for full approval.

Tanker 40 taking off at PEI
Tanker 40, N146FF, taking off at Summerside Airport on PEI, fighting 22 knot crosswinds with gusts to 36 knots. Photo by Rob Sowald, and used with his permission.

If air tankers had feelings, Tanker 40 would be experiencing a culture shock as it leaves snow-covered Prince Edward Island en route to begin its fire season adventures in the United States.

More of Mr. Sowald’s photos can be found on Flickr. Thanks Rob!

Wildfire news, February 26, 2012

There were no earth-shattering stories related to wildfire over the weekend, but here are a few that we noticed:

Fires in western Arkansas

KFSM, a television station in Arkansas, tweeted this satellite photo of fires burning in the west Arkansas counties of Le Flore, Logan, Scott and Johnson. It is dated Saturday, February 25 at 4:30 p.m.

Helicopter pilot volunteers for local fire department

A helicopter pilot who owns and operates a helicopter in Burnet, Texas has been volunteering the use of his helicopter his services as a pilot to assist the Burnet Volunteer Fire Department. When called, Rick Neeley, a professional pilot, donates his time and even the fuel for the helicopter when the fire department needs some eyes in the air to provide additional situational awareness when large vegetation fires are burning in Burnet County.

John Smallwood, a Captain with the department, was quoted by KWTX as saying:  “He’s handy for us. We tell dispatch that we need help with air support and we mention his name. They have his number and he always comes out to help us.”

“(I’m) just kind of giving them some eyes in the sky and letting them see things or know things that they would have no other way of knowing,” Neely affirmed. “God’s just blessed us with a way to help and all these guys are helping out in the way they can and we just get out and help the way we can.”

Smoke from wildfires in Thailand creating issues

Smoke from wildfires is causing problems in Thailand, including health issues and the cancellation of commercial flights for at least one airline. On Sunday officials had planned to survey from a helicopter the Thai-Myanmar border area to assess the fires before sending in firefighters, but poor visibility forced the mission to be cancelled. Here is an excerpt from an article at bangkokpost.com:

The forest fires are spreading on both sides of the Thai-Myanmar border, obstructing air and land transport. A thick haze of smoke is seen over most parts of the border town.

Many residents are being treated for eye irritation and breathing difficulties. The smoke crisis was expected to continue for the next few days as authorities are struggling to put out the fires, Mr Suriya said.

Police have set up security checkpoints on several major roads to warn motorists to exercise extra caution and turn on headlights while driving in poor visibility.

Nok Air, the low-cost airline serving Mae Sot, has been forced to land its aircraft in Phitsanulok for the fourth day because of the poor visibility.

Tanker 40 returns to Missoula

Tanker 40 at Missoula
Tanker 40 arriving at Neptune's hangar at the Missoula airport on Sunday

The jet-powered BAe-146 air tanker that Neptune Aviation is leasing from Tronos returned from Prince Edward Island in Canada today after completing a lengthy scheduled maintenance which normally takes about 21 work days. Tanker 40 arrived at Prince Edward Island on December 24 and returned to Missoula Sunday at 5:30 p.m.

Both Neptune and Minden, with nine and two large air tankers on contract respectively, have been asked by the U.S. Forest Service to begin deploying their air tankers earlier than usual this year, due to the fire seasons becoming longer.

The Washington Post, on aging air tankers

The Washington Post has an article about the U.S. Forest Service’s new strategy for replacing aging air tankers, a topic that we covered on February 10. Here is an excerpt:

===============================================================

…“Trying to figure out the right attributes . . . the right specifications, and . . . working across the variety of land and . . . just coordinating with people takes a bunch of time,” [Tom] Harbour, [national fire director for the Forest Service] said. “We’re happy it’s out. It’s a part of the discussion we have to have with Congress.”

Money also played a role in the agency’s struggle to draft a proposal to modernize. Its pricey shopping list of planes was not acceptable to the Office of Management and Budget.

The agency sought state-of-the-art C-130Js, at $80 million each, a price it cannot afford, according to congressional staffers and aviation experts. The head-turning cargo plane flies at nearly 400 mph and can deliver an optimal load of 4,000 gallons of fire suppressant.

Harbour called the C-130J “an aircraft . . . designed for the kinds of stresses and strains of this work.” As a 20-year investment, he said, it “might be the best thing we could do.”

 

Thanks go out to Dick and Ken

Followup on crack found on P2V air tanker

P2V air tanker on the Whoopup fire
P2V air tanker on the Whoopup fire, 7-18-2011. Photo by Bill Gabbert

Neptune Aviation has provided more information about the 24-inch crack they found on a wing spar and skin on one of their 50+ year old P2V air tankers, which prompted the Federal Aviation Administration to issue an Emergency Airworthiness Directive. The EAD required that all P2V airplanes be inspected within 24 hours of receiving the directive. Neptune and Minden, who operate all 11 of the large air tankers on U.S. Forest Service contracts, which are all P2Vs, did not find any similar cracks on the other aircraft during the FAA required inspections.

Here are some excerpts from a news release provided by the American Helicopter Services and Aerial Firefighting Association:

====================================================

Missoula, MT…Neptune Aviation, the country’s biggest operator of large airtankers, reports that its fleet of ex-Navy P2V Neptunes remains wildfire mission-ready, following the discovery of a crack in the left wing of one of its tankers during a routine scheduled inspection in late January of this year. Although that one airtanker remains out of service pending an engineering evaluation, the remaining nine P2Vs were never grounded–thanks to quick action by the operator.

“We were the ones who discovered the problem and notified the FAA’s Flight Standards District Office (FSDO) in Helena, MT, and at the same time filed a Service Difficulty Report through the FAA’s electronic reporting system,” said Dan Snyder, President of the Missoula-based company. “We then developed inspection criteria, which we took to the FAA’s Aircraft Certification Office (ACO) in Denver after we had inspected our entire fleet. The ACO asked us to provide the details of our inspection criteria, and then used that as the basis for the emergency airworthiness directive (AD), which was issued for all P2V operators in the US.”

[…]

Snyder pointed out that Neptune’s maintenance and inspection criteria are in full compliance with the approved Continuous Airworthiness Program (CAP), implemented by Neptune, and mandated by the US Forest Service (USFS) in 2004. “Neptune Aviation has always been at the forefront of dealing with the aging aircraft issues involved with the current tanker fleet. The fact that we detected this problem before it led to a catastrophic failure indicates that the CAP is doing its job,” he said.

In fact, Neptune Aviation is in the forefront of efforts to replace its Post-World War II tankers. Last year, it secured interim approval from the USFS for deployment of a modified BAE 146 jet, formerly in air carrier service, and is proposing that aircraft for the air tanker role. “We will be responding to the US Forest Service’s Next Generation Tanker Solicitation by the February 15, 2012 deadline,” Snyder reported. “Our intention is to add more aircraft to the US Forest Service airtanker fleet under this solicitation, while continuing to maintain our current P2V tanker fleet.”

USFS announces large air tanker strategy

The U.S. Forest Service issued a news release today saying they were announcing a strategy for replacing aging large air tankers. We have been waiting for a replacement strategy since 2002 when two air tankers independently fell apart in midair killing five crew persons. The repercussions from that, and weeding out some of the most unsuitable old air tankers, resulted in the size of the air tanker fleet decreasing from 44 to the 11 we have today.

The “strategy” announced on a Friday afternoon where news releases go to die, is almost identical to the details that appeared in the Request for Proposals that the USFS issued in November of 2011. As we reported then, the agency may add 7 to 35 25 turbine-powered air tankers to their contracted air tanker fleet. That RFP, which was amended several times, said these “next generation” aircraft must be powered by turbine engines and have a “target” capacity of 3,000 to 5,000 gallons, with 2,400 gallons being the minimum acceptable, and they must be able to cruise at 300 knots (345 mph) at 12,000 feet. Today’s news release differs from those specifications only in that it states the capacity must be “a minimum of 1,800 gallons of retardant with more than 3,000 gallons preferred”. Type 2 air tankers have a 1,800 to 3,000 gallon capacity while a Type 1 air tanker can carry at least 3,000 gallons. Very large air tankers (VLAT) such as Evergreen’s 747 can hold up to 20,000 gallons.

The news release issued today does add one interesting tidbit (emphasis added):

Airtankers provided under contract by private industry will continue to be essential in effective wildland firefighting. Long term, the Agencies will continue to explore the costs and benefits of all types of aircraft and ownership models.

This leaves the door open to adding government owned contractor operated (GOCO) air tankers, or even government owned government operated (GOGO) air tankers to the current situation, which is contractor owned contractor operated (COCO). However, the USFS is extremely, incredibly slow and indecisive, and they are very, very resistant to adopt any new wildfire aviation technologies or aviation platforms. So for them to make any major change, especially to GOCO or GOGO, is inconceivable, in spite of the all-options-are-on-the-table sentiment expressed in the news release..

The excerpt said they will continue to explore the costs and benefits of all types of aircraft. The release also includes this:

The fleet of aircraft that are used for wildland fire suppression also includes water scoopers, single engine airtankers, very large airtankers and helicopters.

This is intended to give the casual reader the impression that the USFS actively encourages and uses all of those types of aircraft, which is not the case. It is very obvious that certain individuals in the USFS have a strong bias against water scoopers and VLATs.

Later we will examine some of the information that is in the $840,092 Rand report. The USFS commissioned Rand to make recommendations about the future of the air tanker program, but refuses to release the pricey report even under a Freedom of Information Act request.